I think the bottom two will be Jason and Brooke. I wish it would be Brooke going but I think it might be Jason.
what does everyone else think?

Hmm I'm agreeing with you on Jason and Brooke. But I think Jason's fanbase might be a little..larger than Brooke's (with fangirls rofl) so I think it could be Brooke's last night.

I'm terribly bummed, I love them both

That's always tough to guess, since I've mostly gotten it wrong lately!

Jason and Brooke both deserve the bottom 2 spots for sure this week.
As far as my prediction on who will be sent home.... I'll say... Brooke, being that she was in the bottom 2 last week, only to bomb again this week. And Jason was safe last week.

Bottom 2: Brooke and Jason

Jason goes home.

PS. Anyone else really suprised Syesha is still there? Personally, I think she should have been kicked off 3 weeks ago.

Yeah I'm going to have to agree with Jason and Brooke being in the bottom. I really wish it wasn't so but after last night I think they are definitely in trouble. And I completely 100% agree that Syesha should have been gone weeks ago. She has a voice, I'll give her that, but until last night...absolutely no stage presence. Who keeps voting for her anyway? Based on all performances she definitely needs to go home before Jason and Brooke, but I don't think that will be the case.

Yet another reason I feel that Brooke will be going home tonight, I love her, I really do but that's twice not hunny not once. Any performer knows, that you NEVER stop and start again...just go on and do the best you can! Sorry girl, I don't know how much Vote For The Worst voting for you is actually going to save you after last night's debacle. Sadly, after she started again she did a damn decent job with it. But again...YOU NEVER...I repeat...NEVER start and stop like that!


http://www.tmz.com/category/american-idol/

I agree :]

Bottom two will definitely be Brooke and Jason, but of course in my pool I had Syesha going home this week. Jason has been consistently good so I don't think he deserves to go home this week but it's a possibility.

I really do have a lot of faith in the ability of Worsters to keep Brooke in this week. Really I think it will be another shocker.

When she messed up on Every Breath You Take, it sounded more like she missed the pitch rather than the word. Maybe it's time for her to watch her first R-rated movie.

Yeah, IMO the bottom 3 should consist of Brooke, Jason and David A., even though I certainly don't think David A. should (or will) go home. I just thought Carly was better last night overall.

The top 2 should be nobody less than David C. and Syesha.

I honestly think it's going to be Brooke. I felt absolutely terrible for Jason last night (he's always been my 2nd favorite)...but I think (or hope) his fans voted enough to keep him another week. I thought that Brooke was the weakest overall...the whole stopping and starting thing really bugged me...so, i will say she's out this week.

I'm assuming it will be Brooke, but you never know.

Jeannine

I would guess that Brooke would be the one going home this week.

Brooke, Jason, and Syesha have all been bottom three the past couple of weeks. Based on performance Brooke should go, but she's got a big fanbase to cover her mistakes. I'd say Syesha though.

I think so too. OR Syesha, Brooke might have more fans than Syesha.. But Brooke wasn't very good now. :s Who knows : P Actually it doesn't matter to me very much is it Brooke or Syesha, as long it's not David C, Jason or Carly. =)

I think it's going to be Brooke or Castro.

hhmm..the two weakest last night were Jason and Brooke. I hope it's not another shocker. I'm thinking maybe Brooke and IDK why but there's a tiny voice inside me telling me to say Syesha. As long as it ain't our D.(anyone else get tons of busy signals when trying to vote??)

When Brooke stopped, I was like "oh no she didn't" and then the judges praised her and called her brave?? WTFSERIOUSLY??

I sorta felt bad for Jason cuz I didn't think it was THAT bad, just one of his weaker preformances. But I really don't care seeing as pretty much everyone else besides David bores me.

Brooke and Jason. I think Brook will be going home. Jason will be going home soon. All he does week after week is the slow songs with not much power. He's a one trick pony...

Brooke's going home. I can see it now.

Brooke seemed to get the kiss of death from Paula. Paula is hardly ever negative but she looked so annoyed. That seems to be her pet peeve with any contestant is how they handle forgetting lyrics or starting over. I did feel quite a bit of weird tension from Brooke. She has never been quiet with the judges or Ryan. If she is voted off, I hope she takes it well.

I think it's going to be Brooke. She hasn't done well for the past two weeks. I liked Jason's performance last night. Sure he struggled with the song a little, but that's definitely one hard song to sing.

i was shocked it was Carley but not at all sad anout it. She seemed overly confident to me. Also I thought it was harsh when she said "I remembered all the words!"