Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Question About What The Judges Say About Adam!
David Cook > The Other Stuff > American Idol (General)
smk1379
They say he is the most original they have ever had on the show?! I don't buy it he did not sing this!................

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wDYIoyYoHnc
smk1379
one of them needs to be deleted I accidently posted twice!
MomOfTwo
I truly love that song! But I do want to say that I listened very carefully to the judges this week and last. Both Randy and Simon said that Adm was ONE of the most/best they have had on the show, not just the best. Maybe pressure got to them. Randy also said that they were ONE of the most talented top 7 they had ever had, which I think is fair. The things that I don't like being said are "Iconic" and "Rock God." Sorry, this is a Bono, Springsteen, Elvis, Beatles catagory, not Adam Lambert. You never know in time for him or anyone, but I don't think its something you say for someone who has been on the national stage for four months. You have to have years to establish that kind of thing.
Jessica
SourceNRG
QUOTE (MomOfTwo @ May 20 2009, 02:19 PM) *
I truly love that song! But I do want to say that I listened very carefully to the judges this week and last. Both Randy and Simon said that Adm was ONE of the most/best they have had on the show, not just the best. Maybe pressure got to them. Randy also said that they were ONE of the most talented top 7 they had ever had, which I think is fair. The things that I don't like being said are "Iconic" and "Rock God." Sorry, this is a Bono, Springsteen, Elvis, Beatles catagory, not Adam Lambert. You never know in time for him or anyone, but I don't think its something you say for someone who has been on the national stage for four months. You have to have years to establish that kind of thing.
Jessica


Boy you can say that again!!!! About the whole Iconic/Rock God thing for Adam. GEEEEEZ!!!!!!! Maybe after a couple DECADES you could say this..... blink.gif .....if he lasts that long.

Sharon
cass877
Oh he will definitely last that long. I think both he and kris will be extremely successful.
Teralynne93
I agree about the rock god comment... come on! I don't think anybody can be classified as a rock god until they've been successful in the business for decades, and have a legacy... so, Adam doesn't fit into that category... and personally, I don't think he ever will, because in my opinion, he doesn't have the potential for longevity as a solo artist. He could last forever on Broadway though, and become iconic there. I definitely see that as a possibility.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2012 Invision Power Services, Inc.