Ok, so we all know that DAVID COOK is our favorite Idol this season and we have discussed our favorites from the past 6 seasons (DAUGHTRY ROCKS!!!!!) But, now let's switch it up a bit.. name ONE Idol from each season you did not like and reason(s) for dislike are optional... Ok, here are mine:

Season 1:
Nikki McKibbin.. (um, she was NOT better than Tamara Gray.)

Season 2:
Clay Aiken- (most overrated Idol- EVER and plus, the Claymates scare me.)

Season 3:
JPL - (almost as much as I could not stand Clay and why is Idol still promoting his CD's- WHO CARES?)

Season 4:
Scott Savol - (he was forgettable and dull- sorry)

Season 5:
Taylor Hicks (um- Soul Patrol?? Yeah, whatever- that's why RCA dumped his ass and that's what he gets for taking Chris spot-- I bet he's mad as hell that the 4TH PLACE runner up is one of the most talked about and successful Idols- EVER!!!) LOL

Season 6:
Sanjaya Malakar (he was ridiculous.. and still is... )

Season 7:
Danny Noriega .. but now that he is gone.. and I kind of like everyone else.. \



Any agree or disagree with me on these?? Let me know....

Actually, I think Taylor is happy he's no longer under a major company's management and now has complete creative control over his own career.

The hate towards other contestants hasn't ever made any sense to me. I think every contestant has something to offer, and each singer gives their fans something to smile about. Sure I've been annoyed that some contestants made it farther than others, but I don't see the point in cutting them down.

I can't recall disliking any particular contestant too much, but I can't stand the ones who just coast by based on popularity. There's a spot-filler every season *AHEM* klc *AHEM* and that annoys me... others are more deserving. I know it's very subjective... that's just my opinion.

SANJAYA.

HANDS DOWN.

He practially ruined all of season 6 for me.

This season Kristy and Carly annoy me alot

This season for me...KLC needs to go!

Constantine Maroulis

That stare, in person, is like your creepy uncle.

*shudders*

KRISTY LEE COOK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Amen. lol

But let's see
Season 2: Carmen Rasmusen
Season 3: Fantasia
Season 4: Scott Savol and Mikayla Gordon
Season 5: Paris Bennett
Season 6: Sanjaya, Haley, Chris Richardson
Season 7: Danny(okay 2nd week, overall NO), Kristy, David A. -idk why but he's kinda annoying to me.

Chris Richardson?!

Season 1:
EJay

Season 2:
Carmen Rasmussen. OMG even watching American Idol Rewind is painful when she's on!

Season 3:
The whole lot? Well, minus JPL. But I actually like him more for his personality than his music. He's such a dork

Season 4:
Bo, Scott Savol, and Constantine

Season 7:
Honestly, I don't care for any of the girls.

i'm sorry to say ... David A. annoys me

i woudl have to agree with u ... but his alsoo really cute in a little kid kind of way

ya right.. but in my opinion he's kinda fake.. i don't know but i don't want to offend anyone so this is just my opinion... maybe he's not

yeaa but i dont really like him ... all my friends love him im the only one who loves david cook

He actually seems genuine to me. Eek, I can't help but like this kid. Not as much as David Cook, of course.

Same here. I don't understand how people can think he's fake. He's a total sweetheart and you can see truly see that. Even Cook has said so.

Quote from Cook:

aww david. a is so cute!
but to be honest..
he's got a great voice but if he doesn't pick it up he wont make it far..
just my opinion
so far we've only heard him do slow songs..
i don't think his voice is right for upbeat ones

anyways
my least favorite this year is amanda
yuckyuckyuck
she seems like a nice person..
i just can't stand her voice

Yeah he's kinda sweet and innocent looking/sounding, but I feel that he sounds fake-ish. It's hard to explain; we all have our instincts.

I've only watched this season (cos of DC on youtube) , and I really think DAvid A does not deserve all the attention he gets. He sounds the exact same in every song, so I was bored to my skull after listening to him on a 3rd performance.

But my least favourite is Ramiele Malubay. She acts like a complete different person in real life. On idol she acts all cute and sensible, but through facebook she is one of those dumb teenagers who do disgusting stuff to look 'cool.'


KLC did not deserve to get through this round.

So generally, I think everyone is amazing. I'm just discriminating a few for the fairness of the votes.
I really think they should make us vote ONLY once per performance.

My least favorite this season is probably Amanda, I don't think she deserves to have made it this far. But I also don't like Kristy Lee Cook.

Season 1: didn't watch
Season 2: didn't watch
Season 3: didn't watch
Season 4: I could not stand Constantine and Mikalah
Season 5:Taylor...I mostly liked everyone else though
Season 6: Sanjaya
Season 7: I don't really like any of the girls except Carly. I really like pretty much all of the guys. But my least fav. is Kristy by a mile.

David A is adorable, but he's so naive. If he does win, 19 is just going to take advantage of his innocence. Whereas David C has knowledge and a background in putting together an actual album. David A would be going into things blindly and thus would probably sing anything they put in front of him.

Which is probably why he should win. They want someone they can mold. I can see David C arguing for what he wants on his album and what he wants to stay away from. The last winner to really take a stand for his music was Taylor and well, look what happened there

very true
but if you think about it..
taylor didn't really have a set style..
whereas carrie underwood was country
and she's doing just fine now with her country music...

Season 1: Nikki McKibbin - Didn't have one fully on-key performance. Just couldn't sing very well.
Season 2: Corey Clark - SLIME BALL.
Season 3: Camile Velasco - See Nikki McKibbin.
Season 4: Scott Savol - Hated his personality. Had a few decent performances, but made it way too far.
Season 5: Taylor Hicks - He seriously won?
Season 6: Sanjaya Malakar - No comment needed.
Season 7: Amy Davis - What the hell was she even doing in the Top 24? Let alone Top 40?

I don't like Sanjaya. But i liked his hair(sarcasticlly speaking of course), he was the only reason why I even watched American Idol last year. I just thought his hair styles were really funny.

6: Sanjaya (that stupid Vote For the Worst site was generating some illegal votes to keep him in the competition). Which I'm glad that it was only up to Jordin and Blake, singing it out in the finale

7: Amanda Overmyer. I give credit to what she's doing which she's a nurse. But as for her singing talent. I'm kind of not a fan of that kind of genre

Scott Savol, Sanjaya, Amanda Overmyer, Haley Scarnato, Taylor, Constantine, Mikaylah, Jessica Sierra, KLC

FAVORITES EVER

Daughtry, David Cook, David Hernandez, David Archuleta, Carrie Underwood and Elliott Yamin

wow this is hard to think of my least fav.. nottttttttttttt its KRISTY LEE COOK KRISTY LEE COOK KRISTY LEE COOK KRISTY LEE COOK KRISTY LEE COOK KRISTY LEE COOK KRISTY LEE COOK KRISTY LEE COOK KRISTY LEE COOK KRISTY LEE COOK KRISTY LEE COOK KRISTY LEE COOK KRISTY LEE COOK KRISTY LEE COOK KRISTY LEE COOK KRISTY LEE COOK KRISTY LEE COOK KRISTY LEE COOK KRISTY LEE COOK KRISTY LEE COOK KRISTY LEE COOK ... srry i just really dont like her

I hate KLC. She's so desperate she bugs me. And she only gets vote because people think she's hot but I think she over shaved her eyebrows.

i totally agree with u.... shes soo uglyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy

Amanda wasn't my favorite, but I definitely think Kristy should have left.
I haven't liked her from the beginning. Even before she started hanging all over David
I just can't stand her style; I think she should have gone last night

And from what little I saw last season, yes, I hated Sanjaya.
When I saw him in the audience last week I flipped out. xD I was like "WE GOT RID OF YOU LAST SEASON! WHY ARE YOU BACK HERE!?"

I hated Sanjaya last season too until I met him this summer.. he was so freaking sweet and huggable that I couldn't hate him anymore. So I decided instead of hating him, I will just say I love him, I just never want to hear him sing EVER EVER again. lol

My favorite idol contestants have been: Kelly, Clay, Chris Daughtry, Carrie, Blake, Chris R, Jordin
My least favorites: All of season 3 (kidding... but most of season 3), Greasy McGreasefest (constantine), Taylor Hicks, and Haley last season.

This season my favorites are: D.C., Archie, and Brooke
My least favorites are: Kristy, Amanda, David H, and Carly

Aw, that makes me not hate him so much if he's such a sweet person.
If he's that sweet, then so be it, just DON'T. SING. ANYMORE. XD

He was SUCH a sweetheart. The only bad thing I have to say... was the old lady that sat beside me at the concert who said "That boy even makes old women think bad things." I was pretty much scarred for life after that.

O_O;; Oh, you poor thing...
I would have had nightmares, I'm sure, lmao

Your icon is pretty fitting for my reaction.

I would have looked at the woman and been like "...kay, see, this is where you start to scar people around you..."

I just looked at her like she was nuts and scooted closer to my friend. Come to find out, that wasn't her seat anyway, so she left shortly there after. lol

Well at least you didn't have to sit next to her the entire time, lol.

True story. Not that it mattered... once Blake and Chris R were on stage, all bad memories of Sanjaya lady seemed to disappear.

Oh my, that is disturbing.... you poor girl!

Yeah, I pretty much wanted to run for my life.

Least favorite----all the girls.

Does anyone even have to ASK who my least favorite was?

I think I can take a few (correct) guesses.

1st five don't count.

Bo Bice I will RAVE about though. Gives an amazing show and one of the NICEST guys.

Least favorite = Corey Clark, no question. He just oozed slime. Constantine was kinda icky to a lesser degree, but I started liking him a few weeks in. Bo was still my #1 of that season though.

Well for winnersI have to say Taylor Hicks.
But for idols in general, I'd say.. Kat McPhee (She was kinda big-headed ) Sanjaya, and KLC

Season 1 - Nikki McKibbin
Season 2 - Carmen Rassmussen
Season 3 - JPL, John Stevens, Fantasia, Jasmine
Season 4 - Carrie Underwood (this ain't Nashville Star, people)
Season 5 - Kat McPhee/Kellie Pickler
Season 6 - Sanjaya, Haley
Season 7 - KLC, Carly