Hu's ur 2nd favorite?


Me, i kinda like the kid Archuleta. & also Syesha. Bout u guys? Hu's ur 2nd fav.?

don't have one ;]
cookie is the only one for me

Carly. She should still be there.

Totally agree.

I actually really like Syesha and I have a huge soft spot for Jason.

DC is the penultimate though. He's the greatest.

Luv Magz

OF COURSE COOK BY A MILE. I ALSO LOVE CARLY & MJ. =( BUT THEY HAVE GRADUATED... SO MY 2ND FAV. IS ARCHULETA NOW.

I think they are all incredibly talented but none of them come close to Cookie so I really don't have a second favorite. It's always been about DC for me!!

Don't really have one, but out of those that are left, probably Syesha, she's upped her game in the last few weeks and I've enjoyed some of her performances. It's been an age since I liked one by either Jason or Archie.

Carly or Michael Johns of those no longer with us (but flaming should be)

I liked Archie in the beginning but I got bored of him so I guess I would go with Syesha

michael johns

I dont have a second! David is my only favorite:D

Michael Johns, who should still be there.

Ditto...

my second favourite is MJ but *sighs*

I don't really have any left, Brooke was the last one. Amanda, Ramiele, Michael.. all gone. Even Kristy. I would like Jason, but if he's ready to go then goodbye.

Michael.

mine was michael. and then carly. and now its just Cookie.

Jason Castrooooo!!!! :DDDDDDD

syesha. i think it's cause i like the whole broadway aspect of her.

Michael Johns was my second favorite. I will also admit to thinking Archie should win after his Imagine performance. However I have since repented my evil ways and have seen the light =)

I don't have a second favorite of the remaining contestants. My picks were always Cookie then Carly.

I don't care too much for Syesha,something about her irks me. Plus,she kinda ruined Vanishing. I don't appreciate....lol.

Archie seems like he has no personality of his own,he's so....scripted.

Jason doesn't even act like he wants to be there anymore. His novelty has worn thin for me at this point.

Cookie is just my favorite.
He's just been my favorite.
I've never had a second favorite.

I could never pick a second one, I have David Cook tunnel vision.

I've never really cared about the other ones, they are like the background props on the show.

I agree with most of you...I can't see anyone else but Cookie....and I actually don't think anyone else is that great because they aren't willing to step out of their comfort zone and change things up.

my 2nd fave is carly..but she's out..
in the top 4, my 2nd is that archuleta guy..

I don't have one.

David is the only one for me.

The same goes for me!

Jason Castro is the only other one I would listen to after idol.

It was Carly now its Syesha.

In the beginning, it was little David and Michael. But Archie started getting boring and MJ is gone now... I still like Archie and I guess you can say he's still my second fave... but noone comes close to DC!!!

David has all the time been only one who's I'm a fan of, but I loved Carly too. Now when she's gone, I HOPE that Jason will be in top 2 with him, even thought I guess it's Archuleta. -.-

idk, i do really think that archie has a lot of talent and also saesha has been doing really well, so its hard to say who my 2nd fav could b. and i do like jason, 2...but David Cook will always be my #1!!!!

I don't really watch anyone but David, but of what I've seen of the rest, my second favorite was Michael. There's honestly not really anyone else I like much...Archie is cute and sure, for a 17 year old he's damn good and he could go on to a great career, he has a kind of easy listening voice and style that appeals to a lot of people, but I personally find his music very monotonous and just kind of devoid. Like every time one of his songs finishes I half expect to hear a DJ come on and say "you're listening to Sunny 104, always playing music to brighten your day!...". Jason...I've only watched him once, but meh. It was alright, I might watch some more of him, but I certainly wasn't blown away. Syesha I haven't watched. Brooke, I loved "I Am, I Said" but that was it. Carly was alright. But really, they all just seem very average to me, except for David <3

im srry...ur signature is the BEST!!!

after David, Jason is my second love this year.

Mine too. Followed closely by MJ and Chikezie. There don't seem to be many Chikezie fans out there, but I loved him and hated seeing him go so soon. I actually think his elimination depressed me even more than MJ's did.

Well...I'll admit...MJ was my overall first pick in the beginning, before "Hello" happened. THEN, I fell in love with David and I started vote-splitting (I know, bad Steph). But then, the week MJ was voted off, I had only voted for David because he didn't have a great performance and I was worried about HIM. I had no worries about MJ...and then he got voted off. So yeah, MJ was always my second favorite, but I don't have one now, it's all David for me

~Steph

It was michael.
and I think that explains why he left. so many people here have said MJ was their second favourite, behind DC. and most fans don't split votes.

and now my second favourite is kind of jason. I am absoloutley in love with his personality, but his music blows hot and cold for me.

NONE... COOKIE IS THE ONLY ONE!!!!!

Cookie is the BOMB! hehe...



he'll always be my baby.....

i liked brooke but its hard to LOVE brooke because she has so many confidence issues.

i think that's what ultimately got her kicked out of the competition.

castro and archie are rediculous - neither can sing anything but a ballad - they have ZERO range of performance and are flat out boring.

syesha is a victim of circumstances. AI voters like divas but not enough to make them win.

My 2nd fav was Brooke, but then I kinda changed to Archie...

Guess who's my #1 fav???

His initials are "DC" ...It's hard to guess, right??

carly.