Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: ***TOP 4 - SPOILERS***
David Cook > The Other Stuff > American Idol (General)
Pages: 1, 2
amm11383
So far they only have Jason's posted, but according to MJ's blog Jason is going to be singing "I Shot the Sheriff" - Bob Marley and "Mr. Tambourine Man" - Bob Dylan

Here's the link http://mjsbigblog.com/season-7-top-4-spoilers.htm

If its true then I think they are good choices for him, but the Bob Marley thing is a little obvious so it makes me skeptical that this is true.
velvetsun
Actually, i don't think I Shot The Sheriff is good choice at all. But then, that's just me.

What I want to know is, why is it that Jason's song choices are always leaked before anyone else? I mean, these are usually right each week, so it's just odd that his are spoiled so much earlier then the others.
huh.gif
amm11383
QUOTE (velvetsun @ May 6 2008, 10:50 AM) *
What I want to know is, why is it that Jason's song choices are always leaked before anyone else? I mean, these are usually right each week, so it's just odd that his are spoiled so much earlier then the others.
huh.gif



I don't know. That's a good point though. I think Jason will do well with "I Shot the Sheriff" if he goes in the Eric Clapton route instead of Bob Marley. But who knows?!?!?!? We'll have to just wait and see I guess. Is it 8pm yet? I need my Cookie fix!
piperlily
Hmmm.... wonder how he'd do with Bob Marley. I think he'd be better doing Simon & Garfunkel, but to be honest, he wants to go home.
Maybe he's picking songs that he just knows and are easy for him -- cuz he WANTS TO GO HOME.

unsure.gif
velvetsun
QUOTE (piperlily @ May 6 2008, 10:54 AM) *
Hmmm.... wonder how he'd do with Bob Marley. I think he'd be better doing Simon & Garfunkel, but to be honest, he wants to go home.
Maybe he's picking songs that he just knows and are easy for him -- cuz he WANTS TO GO HOME.

unsure.gif

I do believe he wants to go home. But, I still can't wrap my mind around those song choices.
Zandra
i Shot The Seriff laugh.gif wtf Jason? I might be actually interesting choice, so hopefully he sings that.
amm11383
Here velvetsun, check this out http://youtube.com/watch?v=JbOqRDrcLPc


I could totally see Jason doing this version and rocking that ukulele again!
piperlily
QUOTE (velvetsun @ May 6 2008, 10:58 AM) *
I do believe he wants to go home. But, I still can't wrap my mind around those song choices.


I just don't think he's putting in the effort anymore. I think that wore off for him a while back now.
As the judges have said, he's not 'himself' anymore.

And what I read in that article about him thinking the 150 balloons sent from his fans for being sick was "weird," or when his brother and friend came to visit and he blew off his practice time... or how he completely messed up with Neil Diamond in not being prepared -- and how obvious it was that he wasn't prepared for ALW.

The boy needs and is crying to go home. When will JC's fans listen?
davidisdevine
I think he's still mellow and having some fun. The only time he seemed a little uptight was when the dolphin made that sudden move--LOL! That was funny as heck. Also, to me, the fans in Vegas were too physical with Jason, especially grabbing at his hair like that.
T.C. Robson
*slaps forehead* Jason, Jason, Jason...just want to shake him and ask, "What are you thinking?!?!"
zoo
QUOTE (davidisdevine @ May 6 2008, 08:14 AM) *
...Also, to me, the fans in Vegas were too physical with Jason, especially grabbing at his hair like that.


That disgusted me. These kids are people just like you and me. You wouldn't want to have your space violated like that, would you? I absolutely don't believe in trying to grab them or even to touch them. I am not above shaking hands with them or giving them a hug should they innitiate it but never take it upon myself to make the first move. I do realize that it is common behavior towards some entertainers, though. I have seen it time and time again with Bo Bice. People would try to grab his hair. I even saw a few times women try to kiss him. I just couldn't get over the lack of consideration towards another human being. That lack of respect has really gotten me angry. I have always believed in giving them their space. I'm sure it would make their experience much more enjoyable for them if everyone did. And, to me, my show of support towards this person includes trying to make sure they have the best experience they can possibly have.

Jeannine
piperlily
QUOTE (zoo @ May 6 2008, 11:35 AM) *
That disgusted me. These kids are people just like you and me. You wouldn't want to have your space violated like that, would you? I absolutely don't believe in trying to grab them or even to touch them. I am not above shaking hands with them or giving them a hug should they innitiate it but never take it upon myself to make the first move. I do realize that it is common behavior towards some entertainers, though. I have seen it time and time again with Bo Bice. People would try to grab his hair. I even saw a few times women try to kiss him. I just couldn't get over the lack of consideration towards another human being. That lack of respect has really gotten me angry. I have always believed in giving them their space. I'm sure it would make their experience much more enjoyable for them if everyone did. And, to me, my show of support towards this person includes trying to make sure they have the best experience they can possibly have.

Jeannine


Well said! I agree, people may get excited, but have some self-control -- show some respect, they're people, too.
BethRiot
aha
i'll be singing along to jason on i shot the sheriff

ive actually been hearing that song alot lately

but w/e
i want to know what david will sing!
velvetsun
I'm really surprised by how quiet the boards are as far as supposed spoilers go today. huh.gif I know most people wait for the TMZ stuff, but usually there are tons of stuff bouncing around about all the contestants by now. Here it is 2pm (est) and we still only have the spoiler about Jason.

*impatiently waiting*
Cookey's Fan
What happende in Vegas on Jason's part was plain appalling, in my opinion.

Sure, these so-called fans want a piece of him, but tuggin' him by his hair is pure barbaric.

On the other hand ... still no news on what Cookey will be singing. Ah well, I'll only know when I watch Idol on TV later tonight. Sighz~ sad.gif
Karen.
QUOTE (velvetsun @ May 6 2008, 01:00 PM) *
I'm really surprised by how quiet the boards are as far as supposed spoilers go today. huh.gif I know most people wait for the TMZ stuff, but usually there are tons of stuff bouncing around about all the contestants by now. Here it is 2pm (est) and we still only have the spoiler about Jason.

*impatiently waiting*



maybe because there's so much to choose from?
velvetsun
QUOTE (d.c.ftw @ May 6 2008, 01:14 PM) *
maybe because there's so much to choose from?

Not sure.
But I'd rather know what he's singing so i can....prepare myself
laugh.gif
SaucyAussieCookFan
I.Shot.The.Sheriff....seriously Jason? Seriously? -hits head on desk-

He REALLY doesn't want to be there does he? Wow...I can't believe he chose that as one of his songs. I just said in another thread that I think he's going to be mocked for choosing that song. I'm not trying to be mean because I like Jason somewhat, I mean I liked him last week when no one else did laugh.gif BUT, I think that's a horrible song choice for him.

As for "Mr. Tambourine Man"...I think he'll do a good job with this one. Although, it might be said that it's too safe and too predictable. But, if he can change it up a little and maybe make it his own (like DC does every week), he might redeem himself after "I Shot The Sheriff"...maybe.

Oh well...the person who really matters is DC. Where are his spoilers! I want to know before I leave for class laugh.gif

Oh, and my song predictions for Jason weren't even close to what he chose laugh.gif I don't even remember "I Shot The Sheriff" being on that list of songs...was it?

~Steph
velvetsun
QUOTE (SaucyAussieCookFan @ May 6 2008, 01:31 PM) *
I.Shot.The.Sheriff....seriously Jason? Seriously? -hits head on desk-

He REALLY doesn't want to be there does he? Wow...I can't believe he chose that as one of his songs. I just said in another thread that I think he's going to be mocked for choosing that song. I'm not trying to be mean because I like Jason somewhat, I mean I liked him last week when no one else did laugh.gif BUT, I think that's a horrible song choice for him.

As for "Mr. Tambourine Man"...I think he'll do a good job with this one. Although, it might be said that it's too safe and too predictable. But, if he can change it up a little and maybe make it his own (like DC does every week), he might redeem himself after "I Shot The Sheriff"...maybe.

~Steph

There are a bunch of people on MJ's blog commenting about how his doing ISTS is his way of showing people he's all about redemption and that he's in it to win it. Frankly, i see it in the opposite way.

As for Mr Tambourine Man? Well..it might work. But tempo wise, it's so incredibly slow and boring (and i'm a Dylan fan).
SaucyAussieCookFan
QUOTE (velvetsun @ May 6 2008, 01:44 PM) *
There are a bunch of people on MJ's blog commenting about how his doing ISTS is his way of showing people he's all about redemption and that he's in it to win it. Frankly, i see it in the opposite way.

As for Mr Tambourine Man? Well..it might work. But tempo wise, it's so incredibly slow and boring (and i'm a Dylan fan).


Redemption? Like you said...I see it as the opposite. When I saw that he was doing that song, I just shook my head and said, "You really want to go home don't you?" LoL

~Steph
velvetsun
K, i had to share this:

Take this with a huge amount of salt people. I'm posting this for mainly entertainment purposes only smile.gif

Over on IDF someone posted a link to a blog entry from someone who 'always' goes to rehearsals.
This person said that Cookie was going to do the songs War & House Of The Rising Sun.

Now...according to the people at IDF this site is always wrong, so i didn't panic about the song choices (War??!), but i have to say the person writing it should go into writing Fan Fic instead. talk about over the top and melodramatic.

Oh, and there was also a comment about how David really wanted to do Anarchy in The UK, but changed his mind at the last minute.

'Fake' song choices from in "insider" tongue.gif

K, maybe it's better to just wait for TMZ. laugh.gif
SaucyAussieCookFan
QUOTE (velvetsun @ May 6 2008, 02:01 PM) *
K, i had to share this:

Take this with a huge amount of salt people. I'm posting this for mainly entertainment purposes only smile.gif

Over on IDF someone posted a link to a blog entry from someone who 'always' goes to rehearsals.
This person said that Cookie was going to do the songs War & House Of The Rising Sun.

Now...according to the people at IDF this site is always wrong, so i didn't panic about the song choices (War??!), but i have to say the person writing it should go into writing Fan Fic instead. talk about over the top and melodramatic.

Oh, and there was also a comment about how David really wanted to do Anarchy in The UK, but changed his mind at the last minute.

'Fake' song choices from in "insider" tongue.gif

K, maybe it's better to just wait for TMZ. laugh.gif


Omg...pleeeeease let "War" be a fake spoiler laugh.gif Just no. Not even David should sing that song LoL

I don't like "House Of The Rising Sun" as a choice for him either.

Just please let these be wrong...-sigh-

~Steph
ande
house of the raising sun??? Muse did a cover of that song...mmmm i dont knowwwwwwww...i hope this is not correct.

war?? ahh no.
SaucyAussieCookFan
I decided to listen to "War" just to see if I could see David doing it, if it happened to be true...and just NO NO NO, David LoL

As soon as it started I couldn't help but start laughing picturing David singing it LoL Especially the "Good God, ya'll" part...laugh.gif laugh.gif

If CARLY was still around, I could see HER possibly doing it, but not DC LoL

I just finished reading the rest of that blog, and they don't even have both of Jason's confirmed spoiled songs right, so who knows?

~Steph
desi
i think war could be really fun!
jason's songs are always spoiled on tuesday's by like, a family friend or something. that's what it said on mj's a couple weeks ago.
velvetsun
QUOTE (SaucyAussieCookFan @ May 6 2008, 02:11 PM) *
I decided to listen to "War" just to see if I could see David doing it, if it happened to be true...and just NO NO NO, David LoL

As soon as it started I couldn't help but start laughing picturing David singing it LoL Especially the "Good God, ya'll" part...laugh.gif laugh.gif

If CARLY was still around, I could see HER possibly doing it, but not DC LoL

I just finished reading the rest of that blog, and they don't even have both of Jason's confirmed spoiled songs right, so who knows?

~Steph

Exactly! That's what i was thinking too. laugh.gif

These are obviously wrong, imo. So relax.

Cookie will knock us all on our collective asses this week...i know he will. wink.gif
Chelsey loves Cookie
What about The Times they are a-changing for jason??
Terrible One
QUOTE (velvetsun @ May 6 2008, 01:30 PM) *
Exactly! That's what i was thinking too. laugh.gif

These are obviously wrong, imo. So relax.

Cookie will knock us all on our collective asses this week...i know he will. wink.gif



He will not be singing "War". Just wait, these two songs that he picked are going to pretty much put the contest out of reach for everyone.
Chelsey loves Cookie
I said somewhere else on the boards that he'll probably sing Like A Virgin and we'll all go " blink.gif WTF?!" and then die of awsomeness.

Archie should sing the letter by the box tops...or a jackson 5 song...Syesha will probably do Aretha or something like that...
velvetsun
QUOTE (Terrible One @ May 6 2008, 02:50 PM) *
He will not be singing "War". Just wait, these two songs that he picked are going to pretty much put the contest out of reach for everyone.

My thoughts exactly. biggrin.gif
Terrible One
He's not singing "Like a Virgin" either. You'll see in a few hours. These songs will be talked about for a long time.
ande
"war" is such a harsh song ...i see him more of a lover not a fighter... wink.gif
desi
i have never spent so much time on the boards in one day and now all these ridiculous song choices are running through my head-- what if baby david sang "like a virgin?" how funny!
i blame the waning anesthesia from my surgery this morning.
BSDCfan
QUOTE (velvetsun @ May 6 2008, 05:01 PM) *
Over on IDF someone posted a link to a blog entry from someone who 'always' goes to rehearsals.
This person said that Cookie was going to do the songs War & House Of The Rising Sun.


That's not what I've heard.......

but my lips are sealed!!


Chelsey loves Cookie
War would just suck...
SaucyAussieCookFan
QUOTE (Chelsey loves Cookie @ May 6 2008, 03:00 PM) *
War would just suck...


Wow, tell us your real feelings, Chelsey laugh.gif laugh.gif Just kidding, I feel the same way LOL

~Steph
Chelsey loves Cookie
http://youtube.com/watch?v=9muzyOd4Lh8

this song?? I could see it...somewhat...my spideypowernote senses are tingling...
velvetsun
QUOTE (BSDCfan @ May 6 2008, 03:00 PM) *
That's not what I've heard.......

but my lips are sealed!!

I stated further on in the post that those were probably fake song choices. rolleyes.gif

At least someone knows what Cookie is singing...other then Cookie laugh.gif
Chelsey loves Cookie
and I'm maybe sensing some Stevie Wonder for Archie...

But I want Michael to come back....do some doors again or just generally be awsome...maybe he'll duet with Cookie in a surprise guest appearance?! LOL
SaucyAussieCookFan
-sighs- I never get to see the song spoilers before I leave for class. I have to leave around 7 and I usually get off of the computer around 6:30 to get ready to leave, so I never see the spoilers sad.gif I wish they'd post them early for once so I could see them. I really want to know before I leave LoL

~Steph
velvetsun
QUOTE (Chelsey loves Cookie @ May 6 2008, 03:15 PM) *
and I'm maybe sensing some Stevie Wonder for Archie...

But I want Michael to come back....do some doors again or just generally be awsome...maybe he'll duet with Cookie in a surprise guest appearance?! LOL

I've heard Archie may be doing Supersticious & Bridge Over Troubled Water OR Stand By Me.
Chelsey loves Cookie
Supersticious is what i had in mind
SaucyAussieCookFan
Well here we go for Archie. It was just posted on http://slimtainment.com/idolblog/ and she's (he's? lol) usually right, so here's Archie's:

"Stand By Me" by B.E. King and "Love Me Tender" by Elvis Presley.

What do you think? Neither of those were my choices for him, yet again. This is becoming a pattern for me today LOL I think those two choices are awfully boring for Archie. I definitely wouldn't have picked them for him, especially because they're both ballads...*shrugs*

Maybe DC will be next! *prays*

~Steph
BethRiot
Hopefully in the next hour
we will find out what David will sing.
velvetsun
QUOTE (SaucyAussieCookFan @ May 6 2008, 03:19 PM) *
Well here we go for Archie. It was just posted on http://slimtainment.com/idolblog/ and she's usually right, so here's Archie's:

"Stand By Me" by B.E. King and "Love Me Tender" by Elvis Presley.

What do you think? Neither of those were my choices for him, yet again. This is becoming a pattern for me today LOL

Maybe DC will be next! *prays*

~Steph

Wait....Archie is singing Love Me F***ing Tender? blink.gif
Great...I have another performance to look forward to with all the 12 year olds screaming at him like he's Tom Jones.
That...just creeps me out.
Terrible One
Baba O'Riley by The Who
Hungry Like The Wolf by Duran Duran
velvetsun
QUOTE (Terrible One @ May 6 2008, 03:24 PM) *
Baba O'Riley by The Who
Hungry Like The Wolf by Duran Duran

blink.gif

wha?
Um...
*picks self up off floor*
Are you saying those are David's songs?
*lays back on floor*
laugh.gif
Chelsey loves Cookie
QUOTE (velvetsun @ May 6 2008, 12:23 PM) *
Wait....Archie is singing Love Me F***ing Tender? blink.gif
Great...I have another performance to look forward to with all the 12 year olds screaming at him like he's Tom Jones.
That...just creeps me out.


Elvis? Danny Noregia sang Elvis. It scared me...*hides*
velvetsun
QUOTE (Chelsey loves Cookie @ May 6 2008, 03:27 PM) *
Elvis? Danny Noregia sang Elvis. It scared me...*hides*

I'm still trying to get past what Terrible One posted.
Can't. Process. Thoughts.
Terrible One
QUOTE (velvetsun @ May 6 2008, 02:27 PM) *
blink.gif

wha?
Um...
*picks self up off floor*
Are you saying those are David's songs?
*lays back on floor*
laugh.gif

That is correct
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.