David Cook > Randy is a rat!!

David Cook > The Other Stuff > American Idol (General)

Pages: 1, 2

bat-chen

May 15 2008, 07:49 AM

QUOTE (lovedavid_xx @ May 14 2008, 07:54 PM)

he was being f***ing ridiculous! Cookie sounded amazing, and he was just being a brat cause his song choice wasn't as good. Predictable, psh.

And he reallly needs to stop being so incredibly biased towards Archie. He pretty much sucked and was incredibly boring and Randy still loved him. And the whole "you could sing the phonebook" thing is getting so old. Just cause he's a cute 17 year old doesn't mean he should be treated any differently than the others cause he won't be favored once idol is over.

I've totally lost all respect for Randy

You lost?! I never had any respect to him. his the worst judge ever and not only because David Cook but also beacuse he doesn't talks like his age. this all "Dowg... you my dowg..." or any other expression that he saying, are just ridicules and embarrassing.

Nurse_KJ

May 15 2008, 10:04 AM

QUOTE (Sleela @ May 14 2008, 06:27 PM)

Hahaha, yeah, maybe that's what Randy meant.

Randy: "David, dude, I don't know, it's like every week you come out here and you're really awesome and you just blow us away... it's gettin' kind of predictable for me, dawg. I'd like to see you come out and just really suck it up for once."
David: "OK... I'll try..."
(For his next song, DC somehow manages to turn the "La Bamba" into an amazing rock ballad.)
Randy: "Dude, David, that was totally awesome again, man... can't you do ANYTHING wrong?"

That was hilarious! Yea, I think that's exactly what Randy was meaning to say, it just didn't come out right.

MsTambourineGirl

May 15 2008, 05:22 PM

There's a few things that really bothered me the other night ....

1. The obvious. Randy just plain doesn't know what he's talking about ... practically always. He thinks that since he works with big-named artists that he's "cool." I must say, EVERY time I see him playing guitar it cracks me up. I can NOT take it seriously. He's standing up there ... like, "bopping" or something. Just thinking about it makes me laugh

2. I've already admitted that I'm a huge Jason fan. So the fact the judges didn't bring it up that Archuleta flubbed his "With You" lyrics just irriates the hell out of me, frankly. All three judges were quick to point out the fact that Jason blanked on the "Mr. Tambourine Man" lyrics, yet none brought up the fact Archie stumbled thru the first 25 seconds of "With You" like a drunk rat.

I wish they would just admit the judges are biased. I honestly think it would make it easier to watch. We would know when to listen and when to mute the television.

kookyC

May 15 2008, 05:30 PM

QUOTE (MsTambourineGirl @ May 15 2008, 06:22 PM)

2. I've already admitted that I'm a huge Jason fan. So the fact the judges didn't bring it up that Archuleta flubbed his "With You" lyrics just irriates the hell out of me, frankly. All three judges were quick to point out the fact that Jason blanked on the "Mr. Tambourine Man" lyrics, yet none brought up the fact Archie stumbled thru the first 25 seconds of "With You" like a drunk rat.

I wish they would just admit the judges are biased. I honestly think it would make it easier to watch. We would know when to listen and when to mute the television.

yup. i agree. but the wonderful thing about this show is that they judges don't choose the winner, America does.

This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.