Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: TOP TWO DISCUSSON THREAD
David Cook > American Idol Archive > Episode Discussions: During American Idol
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32
traceface4cookie
what are stats on the z-site? vs. D.I.?
Cookin4me
Simon knows what he's doing and he wants David C. to win this thing. Don't despair.
Chris_
QUOTE (traceface4cookie @ May 20 2008, 09:56 PM) *
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/24730875/

AI PRODUCERS ARE REALLY ON OUR SIDE....REALLY!!!!!!!!!!!!!


all archie does is say gosh & make it look like he says thank you but he never puts the microphone up to hs mouth and say it. he is such a puppet. If DA wins, it win be a fluke like season 2 & 5. Clay should have beaten Ruben, and Daughtry should have not been voted off in 4th place.. he sould have trampled Taylor in the finale.

AI needs a rocker as the winner and DC will definately go tripple platinum or better on his first major recording album. Yes... i said it... and he may just surpass Daughtry's success.
getshorty
QUOTE (velvetsun @ May 20 2008, 10:00 PM) *
All i can say is...i lost a ton of respect for Simon tonight. He goes on tv and praises Cook to high heaven, only to be incredibly harsh with his comments tonight. My heart completely broke when he finished his last song, and he started crying. As someone else mentioned...like he was crushed that his best wouldn't be enough. I've said it in other threads...but they have forever lost me as a viewer, regardless of what the results are tomorrow.

I just wanna go and give him a big hug and let him know his Word Nerds didn't give up on him.


I too was crushed by Simon's comments, BUT he could have done us the best favor EVER!!!!! And he knows that.

This has propelled me to vote like I've never voted before. I have faith!

DC for the win!
DavidC_is_the_1_4_me
QUOTE (velvetsun @ May 21 2008, 12:00 AM) *
All i can say is...i lost a ton of respect for Simon tonight. He goes on tv and praises Cook to high heaven, only to be incredibly harsh with his comments tonight. My heart completely broke when he finished his last song, and he started crying. As someone else mentioned...like he was crushed that his best wouldn't be enough. I've said it in other threads...but they have forever lost me as a viewer, regardless of what the results are tomorrow.

I just wanna go and give him a big hug and let him know his Word Nerds didn't give up on him.


Ditto. I wanted to throw something at Simon. Something heavy. And I wanted to hug David, too. Poor thing... (Uh, I sound like my grandma!)
shannabelle
DC 43.93

Archie 31.71
lakers_ferrari
The more i read.. the more i feel like i'm being scam, snub, duped.. watever you call it..
If the producers doesn't want DA to win then why are the judges doing their very best to make it look like a total one sided show instead of a fair fight of who is the best!! I don't know... I have been watching AI ever since it came on air here (Season 3) and have never wanted someone to win this badly.. Not even Daughtry but close enough.. If he doesn't win, I'm determined to stop watching altogether!!
HOOK'D ON COOK
Hey all you West Coasters, we are half way done! But don't stop now DC needs us!!!! Keep Voting!!!!
willow
Crunching a few Dial Idol numbers here at 2 in the morning...last week Dial Idol handled a total of approx. 385,000 calls. Tonight so far with still a few more West Coast hours to go, Dial Idol handled 887,370 calls. Last week 49% of all phone calls (whether busy or votes) made through DI were to David Cook's three numbers. So far tonight, 63% of DI calls were made to David Cook's 3 numbers.

Dial Idol has always correctly predicted the winner. And this season, the only time Dial Idol was wrong about anything was when KLC got voted off and DI had her "safe." David Cook has been in First place on Dial Idol the last 5 weeks (sometimes tied w/ another contestant, sometimes alone.) Last year Jordin was in First place (alone or tied w/ another contestant) the 4 weeks before she won.

I'm cautiously optimistic, but not 100 percent confident of a DC win Wednesday night. There's still the unknown text message factor. It's reported that DA gets more texts than DC, but DC gets more phone calls than DA and my educated guess would be that more phone calls are made than text messages.

I have such mixed feelings about tonight's performances. I had hoped that DC would have really knocked everyone's socks off, but I also thought that Simon was overly critical, especially since he's been all over the press the past few weeks praising DC. But maybe it was reverse psychology, maybe Simon was trying to avoid that "kiss of death" that comes if Simon praises you. Maybe it was to make us so stinking mad that we would vote that much harder.

Dial Idol acted up on me, I had to reset it a few times and eventually resorted to dialing my phone myself, which yielded 336 votes, including the paltry handful of cell phone votes we could get in here and there. My texting was a bit faster than last week, got in a total of 710. My Dial Idol numbers are a bit off, but that was approx. 750.

Ugh, I hope this not a sign of things to come...I just burnt the cookies I was making. sad.gif
Chris_
QUOTE (traceface4cookie @ May 20 2008, 10:04 PM) *
what are stats on the z-site? vs. D.I.?

they havent been updated so dont count right now
queenD
my heart was torn after he had sung his last song and cried and when paula stood up and applauded him.i agree with simon, he is truly a genuine person.
Christiney
Ok...idk if this is off limits
If it is
Sorry In advance
But I just read this from this site http://www.kansascity.com/105/story/629134.html

In the theater, Cook’s fans gave it a long, loud response. As he finished, Cook stepped away from the microphone and fought back tears. If it’s because his ailing brother, Adam, was not able to attend the show (or worse), no one has said so.


Sooo whoever said he was there...I think you saw someone else
sad.gif

BTW I 1567 times
Hope it helps
DavidsRockerPrincess
11:05 West Cosrters keep going You guys can do this I know You can!!!! Cookie For The Win!!!!!! Dial Idol makes me happy can some one post the current standings I really want to know!!!! Vote!!! Vote!!! Vote!!!
Machado
Im still pissed about Daughtry!!! wink.gif
dabri99
I think he started to cry after he performed because it was finally over. He did all he could do before the votes and I think all the emotions just came out because he didn't have to worry or stress over anything anymore.

anyway I'm keeping on voting till I pass out. I'm going to be so horrible at work tomorrow.
wolfsister
QUOTE (Stefanie @ May 20 2008, 08:54 PM) *
what time does the voting end for the west coasters?


West coast can vote till 1:am and it's only me with one cell phone..We shut of the landline..
So do you think it's even worth my efforts?? Even if some think not, I'm not gonna stop till 1am!!! One person can make a difference!!! Right? huh.gif Click to view attachment
getshorty
QUOTE (willow @ May 20 2008, 10:07 PM) *
Crunching a few Dial Idol numbers here at 2 in the morning...last week Dial Idol handled a total of approx. 385,000 calls. Tonight so far with still a few more West Coast hours to go, Dial Idol handled 887,370 calls. Last week 49% of all phone calls (whether busy or votes) made through DI were to David Cook's three numbers. So far tonight, 63% of DI calls were made to David Cook's 3 numbers.

Dial Idol has always correctly predicted the winner. And this season, the only time Dial Idol was wrong about anything was when KLC got voted off and DI had her "safe." David Cook has been in First place on Dial Idol the last 5 weeks (sometimes tied w/ another contestant, sometimes alone.) Last year Jordin was in First place (alone or tied w/ another contestant) the 4 weeks before she won.

I'm cautiously optimistic, but not 100 percent confident of a DC win Wednesday night. There's still the unknown text message factor. It's reported that DA gets more texts than DC, but DC gets more phone calls than DA and my educated guess would be that more phone calls are made than text messages.

I have such mixed feelings about tonight's performances. I had hoped that DC would have really knocked everyone's socks off, but I also thought that Simon was overly critical, especially since he's been all over the press the past few weeks praising DC. But maybe it was reverse psychology, maybe Simon was trying to avoid that "kiss of death" that comes if Simon praises you. Maybe it was to make us so stinking mad that we would vote that much harder.

Dial Idol acted up on me, I had to reset it a few times and eventually resorted to dialing my phone myself, which yielded 336 votes, including the paltry handful of cell phone votes we could get in here and there. My texting was a bit faster than last week, got in a total of 710. My Dial Idol numbers are a bit off, but that was approx. 750.

Ugh, I hope this not a sign of things to come...I just burnt the cookies I was making. sad.gif


Thanks so much for the analysis. We still have time West Coast, let's widen the DI gap!
cookielust
the DI scores are decreasing. sad.gif
Cookey's Fan
QUOTE (Chris_ @ May 21 2008, 02:04 PM) *
AI needs a rocker as the winner and DC will definately go tripple platinum or better on his first major recording album. Yes... i said it... and he may just surpass Daughtry's success.

Yes! Yes! I'm with you on that. For once, please give us a rocker for an American Idol - and DC is The One!!
traceface4cookie
QUOTE (lakers_ferrari @ May 20 2008, 10:05 PM) *
The more i read.. the more i feel like i'm being scam, snub, duped.. watever you call it..
If the producers doesn't want DA to win then why are the judges doing their very best to make it look like a total one sided show instead of a fair fight of who is the best!! I don't know... I have been watching AI ever since it came on air here (Season 3) and have never wanted someone to win this badly.. Not even Daughtry but close enough.. If he doesn't win, I'm determined to stop watching altogether!!


YEP, well they (TPTB again are freaking out because they had to give props to little David tonight) but they know they are going to lose some MAJOR cred and major dollars with DA. Both in declining viewership because this will be their proverbial and FINAL "jump the shark" moment (when it all just gets too ridiculous to watch anymore).

Again, Dadchuletta is going to be A NIGHTMARE and they don't want to deal with him and they will have to for a long while (not sure when legally David can become emancipated to negotiate his contracts and produce his albums without his parents hovering.

PRAY FOR DC, VOTE FOR DC, THE AI TPTB are counting on us too!
tcyrkin
Dialidol predict David Cook the WINNER with no margin of ERROR! Let's hope they are right!
http://www.dialidol.com/asp/predictions/Predictions.asp
Christiney
From the same article
How sad yet beautiful
David
poor thing

After that, the show paused for a commercial. Cook shed his guitar and microphone, then started to exit when a stage hand motioned him to his mother, Beth Foraker, who had approached the stage. He went to where she was standing, buried his face in her shoulder, and they embraced.
BethRiot
QUOTE (tcyrkin @ May 21 2008, 02:13 AM) *
Dialidol predict David Cook the WINNER with no margin of ERROR! Let's hope they are right!
http://www.dialidol.com/asp/predictions/Predictions.asp


I believe dial idol.
biggrin.gif

And just wow.
Tonight was amazing,
It's 2 in the morning
and it's been like an hour since voting got done.
I'm just done for tonight.
I can't wait till David wins.
I'm so happy for him.
He deserves it and you know what?



He's got it!
HOOK'D ON COOK
QUOTE (wolfsister @ May 20 2008, 10:09 PM) *
West coast can vote till 1:am and it's only me with one cell phone..We shut of the landline..
So do you think it's even worth my efforts?? Even if some think not, I'm not gonna stop till 1am!!! One person can make a difference!!! Right? huh.gif Click to view attachment


Keep voting! Every vote counts. Since it is later in the voting time frame more of your votes will go through! Keep going!!!
DavidsRockerPrincess
QUOTE (Machado @ May 20 2008, 10:08 PM) *
Im still pissed about Daughtry!!! wink.gif


Me too He is doing good though top selling band of last year Yay!!! Hes way more famous than Taylor Hicks probubly will ever be that shows Us who should have won!!! I love Chris too!!! I have to say Axium and Daughtry are my 2 fave bands as of late!!! David has such a voice hes truly magnificent!!! He rocked tonight!!!! Chris is still my fave next to Kelly Clarkson!!!! Daughtry is awsome hes really made a name for himself post Idol good for him!!!! Cookie for the win he like Chris did deserves this!!!
BethRiot
QUOTE (Christiney @ May 21 2008, 02:16 AM) *
From the same article
How sad yet beautiful
David
poor thing

After that, the show paused for a commercial. Cook shed his guitar and microphone, then started to exit when a stage hand motioned him to his mother, Beth Foraker, who had approached the stage. He went to where she was standing, buried his face in her shoulder, and they embraced.


Oh wow
That makes me cry
sad.gif
Chris_
Dial Idol scores:

David Cook 43.57

David Archuleta 31.41








Cobbler
Obviously I have not seen the show. I just read your comments and they made me cry a little.
Then I struggled with the original-Gizmo thing, and boy was it putting up a hard fight. I think I got about 50 votes in and that's not much, but hey it's more than zero so I've decided to be content with myself. If it turns out to be a really close run, my 50 might as well be the ones that turns it, right ?
Catlover
QUOTE (Cookin4me @ May 20 2008, 06:24 PM) *
I don't want to tick anyone off here and I have yet to read the previous comments because my husband and I just finished watching AI. But...I have to say that Archuleta was pretty fantastic tonight regardless of what you may think of him. He has never been my favorite but you have to concede that he was in his element tonight and, as Randy said, picked a good time to peak. Having said that, David Cook was also very good but after much discussion between my husband and myself, I think overall, it was not the best song choices. I wish he had chosen an all time classic rock song to end the show with. Something that everyone could identify with; something that just totally rocked. You know what I'm talking about. As the judges have often said, song choice, song choice, song choice.

Now as I'm getting pelted with rotten apples I also have to add that I would not bother to see Archuleta in concert. I just wouldn't put money out for a concert of his. I WOULD DEFINITELY pay to see David Cook and I plan to do just that some day in the very near future. He will be very famous one day and probably accepting a grammy in the near future. He is amazing to me and I still hope he wins this thing.



You know, I got chills when DC sang "I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For". My husband and I were fantasizing about him opening for U2 in a couple of years when they hopefully have another album out and go on tour. Having said that, I agree with you that DA was totally in his element tonight and did an awesome job. I thought "Don't Let the Sun Go Down On Me" was perfect for him. I didn't like that he did "Imagine" again. I agree with DC that it's a journey of growth, and that it doesn't seem right to go back to the beginning of the competition, just because a song performance received great reviews.

I want DC to win, but he doesn't need to win to become huge. He is so incredibly talented and versatile, he can do anything, and his future is going to be amazing. I can't wait to go see him in concert and to buy his first non-cover album. DA will do well too, whether he wins, or not. I will probably buy his album too, although I prefer more upbeat music, but his voice is amazing too and pleasant to listen to.

It's all good, but I'm still in love with DC smile.gif)
Chris_

Dial Idol scores:

David Cook 43.49

David Archuleta 31.35


gap dreasing... not good!
lakers_ferrari
Btw, BethRiot.. I tink that it would be more appropiate to change

Congrats David Cook.
You've just won American Idol

to

Congrats David Cook.
You've just won WORLD IDOL!!

Talk about having fans from all over the world!! We are all a solid PROOF!!
Chris_
i wish i knew how mny votes i have got in... ive been goin nearly nonstop since
Christiney
Ummm
Did DA seem a little annoyed in the begining of the after the finale interview from FOX
He seemed like he was rolling his eyes at one point
Like "Can I get this over with?"
Or am I just "Imagineing" this?
CookieHoney
QUOTE (tcyrkin @ May 20 2008, 10:13 PM) *
Dialidol predict David Cook the WINNER with no margin of ERROR! Let's hope they are right!
http://www.dialidol.com/asp/predictions/Predictions.asp

I don't care what they say... weird things can happen, so I am typing with one hand and hitting redial with the other right now! laugh.gif
Chris_
QUOTE (Christiney @ May 20 2008, 10:26 PM) *
Ummm
Did DA seem a little annoyed in the begining of the after the finale interview from FOX
He seemed like he was rolling his eyes at one point
Like "Can I get this over with?"
Or am I just "Imagineing" this?



were did you see a finale interview?
cookie jar
QUOTE (queenD @ May 21 2008, 01:57 AM) *
i cannot get through with the lines....all 3 were busy. it makes me wanna cry :cry:i am ashamed that you guys were like voting for him non-stop and still i cannot get in. i wanted him to win Badly. :cry: He so deserve this..archuleta may had win the night but our cookie here had surely won the entire competition.


queen:

you're not going to get through anymore if you are using gizmo... you can stop.

gizmo dials in as an east coast number and lines are closed now... all you are going to get is a busy signal
velvetsun
QUOTE (CookieHoney @ May 21 2008, 01:27 AM) *
I don't care what they say... weird things can happen, so I am typing with one hand and hitting redial with the other right now! laugh.gif

Exactly...do not let these DI numbers stop you from voting. Remember, it's not counting the text vote, which everyone assumes Archie does better in.

VOTE!!!!
Christiney
this wasnt posted?
I thought someone woulda posted it by now
Sorrrryyy

http://www.myfoxkc.com/myfox/pages/Enterta...mp;pageId=7.1.1
cookie jar
QUOTE (velvetsun @ May 21 2008, 02:00 AM) *
All i can say is...i lost a ton of respect for Simon tonight. He goes on tv and praises Cook to high heaven, only to be incredibly harsh with his comments tonight. My heart completely broke when he finished his last song, and he started crying. As someone else mentioned...like he was crushed that his best wouldn't be enough. I've said it in other threads...but they have forever lost me as a viewer, regardless of what the results are tomorrow.

I just wanna go and give him a big hug and let him know his Word Nerds didn't give up on him.

i'm pretty sure those weren't tears of defeat...

he was emotionally invested in the song and the moment and he became overwhelmed. i'm sure his journey on idol and how far he had come and what was about to happen soon for him was all coming to a head.
dc4beth
my heart goes with him when he cried....i really really prayed for Cookie to win...i voted through Gizmo and got through 50x... i hope the 25 votes through Gizmo5 will also be counted because i placed around 1000 votes thru this.
BethRiot
QUOTE (Christiney @ May 21 2008, 02:30 AM) *
this wasnt posted?
I thought someone woulda posted it by now
Sorrrryyy

http://www.myfoxkc.com/myfox/pages/Enterta...mp;pageId=7.1.1


Most def thanks for posting this!

Look at his sex hair
it was amazing tonight
cookie jar
QUOTE (traceface4cookie @ May 21 2008, 02:04 AM) *
what are stats on the z-site? vs. D.I.?

zaba will not be updated until 8am
Christiney
Oh NP
all the goodness u gals give me

and...I checked and he is slightly rolling his eyes
Look and watch very closely
its like a side-roll eye thing
Cobbler
If your fingers are tired from dialing - you can borrow mine for a couple of hours. I have no use for them right now.
DavidsRockerPrincess
QUOTE (willow @ May 20 2008, 10:07 PM) *
Crunching a few Dial Idol numbers here at 2 in the morning...last week Dial Idol handled a total of approx. 385,000 calls. Tonight so far with still a few more West Coast hours to go, Dial Idol handled 887,370 calls. Last week 49% of all phone calls (whether busy or votes) made through DI were to David Cook's three numbers. So far tonight, 63% of DI calls were made to David Cook's 3 numbers.

Dial Idol has always correctly predicted the winner. And this season, the only time Dial Idol was wrong about anything was when KLC got voted off and DI had her "safe." David Cook has been in First place on Dial Idol the last 5 weeks (sometimes tied w/ another contestant, sometimes alone.) Last year Jordin was in First place (alone or tied w/ another contestant) the 4 weeks before she won.

I'm cautiously optimistic, but not 100 percent confident of a DC win Wednesday night. There's still the unknown text message factor. It's reported that DA gets more texts than DC, but DC gets more phone calls than DA and my educated guess would be that more phone calls are made than text messages.

I have such mixed feelings about tonight's performances. I had hoped that DC would have really knocked everyone's socks off, but I also thought that Simon was overly critical, especially since he's been all over the press the past few weeks praising DC. But maybe it was reverse psychology, maybe Simon was trying to avoid that "kiss of death" that comes if Simon praises you. Maybe it was to make us so stinking mad that we would vote that much harder.

Dial Idol acted up on me, I had to reset it a few times and eventually resorted to dialing my phone myself, which yielded 336 votes, including the paltry handful of cell phone votes we could get in here and there. My texting was a bit faster than last week, got in a total of 710. My Dial Idol numbers are a bit off, but that was approx. 750.

Ugh, I hope this not a sign of things to come...I just burnt the cookies I was making. sad.gif


My mom was thinking the same thing about the reverse phycolagy. I hope shes right!!!! People at my mom's work say if David Cook dosn't win that they will stop watching AI honestly if they wanted him to win bad enough to say that they would vote. My mom says people her age don't vote shes 55 and that no one at her work votes!!! Grrr!!!!! I'm kinda peved people need to vote for Cookie He deserves this more than anyone in AI history!!!!! Vote!!!!!
Minzhi's Cooker
YEs KEEP VOTING!!!! Don't stop!
BLake
QUOTE (willow @ May 21 2008, 01:07 AM) *
Ugh, I hope this not a sign of things to come...I just burnt the cookies I was making. sad.gif


Oh, willow! Thank you for that (and your thoughtful post).

This li'l statement made me LOL (of course, it could be the sleep deprivation). I do hope you're talking about munchies, though, and not our David! wink.gif
Chris
can I at least borrow your thumb? The side of mine is killing me from hitting the side of the buttons. I've got 658 votes in so far, husbrat (whoever said tht first I love you!!) has given up on me and went to bed and I can dial and post in peace.
cookie jar
QUOTE (willow @ May 21 2008, 02:07 AM) *
Ugh, I hope this not a sign of things to come...I just burnt the cookies I was making. sad.gif


haha... let's hope not wink.gif
velvetsun
QUOTE (cookie jar @ May 21 2008, 01:33 AM) *
zaba will not be updated until 8am

Travis has already said the site is a hoax and not to believe what they post as 'results' anyhow. When they're wrong, they change their prediction to reflect what actually happened. DI has always been trustworthy, so i am putting my faith in them (even though i realize they don't count text votes)
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.