im crying right now

Keep it positive people! He's doing way beyond great and we all know it.

-melts-

whats he singing?

same here... they are so mean!!!!!!!!!

OMG he's crying!

Holy crap he's crying. And now I'm crying. Aw man.

He's crying....and now I'm crying....

Damn it, I'm crying.

is he really crying? seriously? oh i love this man.

HE'S CRYING! CRYING!!! HE DID GREAT!!! OMGGGGGG IMG GNA CRY

Gosh they cut to his teary face and my heart jumped out of my chest. Simon is still...um. Yeah. You all are thinkin' it too. Haha.

Randy-- Yo yo yo yo... you're showing all sides, this was very sensitive... very nice job...

Paula-- you're standing in your truth, your originality, I applaud you...

Simon-- you are one of the nicest, most sincere contestants we've ever had...
but it was completely and utterly the wrong song... should have sung Billie Jean or Hello...

oh. my. god.

I'm in LOVE.


simon needs to rot....now.

Randy: very nice, sensitive side of David Cook. Kinda record you could maybe definitely get by with. (DC tearing up)

Paula: Look at you up on that stage and you're standing in your truth and you're deliveirng unbelievable songs with integrity and originality

Simon: Publicly that you are one of the nicest, most sincere contestants we've ever had. Thought that was a beautiful song, but I'm gonna be honest with you -- completely and utterly the wrong choice for you on this night. Should have sung Billie Jean and Hello

Randy: Wrong song choice in the competition for tonight

DC: For me, this whole thing has been a progression -- so why do something I've already done? (crowd cheers) For the record, I completely understand what you're saying

Sorry for the typos - trying to keep up

oh man, whats wrong?!!!!

Mariah Carey and David Cook? Very cool. Very hot!

C-A-N-N-O-T W-A-I-T!!!

I love it!!!

"This is a progression, so why do something I already did???"

now im tearing up =( .....and i havent even watched the show....

god, im going to vote sooooooooo much 2nite............nothing's goiong to stop me

i'm in love with david cook

Oh GOD!
I hate American idol...

Oh no, crying in a good way...It was an emotional song. He got caught up in it.

what's happening? damn gizmocall is acting up i can't dial out.

T______T
damn it, now I'm crying.

I HAD TEARS IN MY EYES GUYS!!!! He did beautifully!

Simon has completely undermined everything. We have to vote our butts off.

im so crying too.

WHAT THE **** SIMON??

and WELL SAID MR COOK

Amen. Vocals were impeccable. Simon's comments will work in DC's favor, I think. People know good rock music and great versatility when they see it - if Cook doesn't win it, he will have been severely robbed.

What the... no, no, no, NO

Everyone... vote til your fingers bleed!

yea i know!

I hate Simon I hate Simon I hate Simon.

Good luck with voting everyone! Remember, its not over until the polls close!!!!

omg i am crying from the song. DC crying! wow i thought he was incredible!

He actually made me cry BEFORE he started crying! Then I cried harder when I saw him! It would break my heart if he doesn't win! And I don't know why I'm crying! I'm just mad thinking about it! I like how he DIDN'T take the Archie...I mean cheap route! Sorry, but that's cheap! In my opinion!

i'm crying

I'm in love with David Cook too.
That was beautiful. The world I know is a beautiful song. Love it love it love it.

guys u all have to vote

i think simon is trying to get us all angry so that we will vote twice as much..cuz we all know that his performances were amazing

so everyone VOTE until ur fingers bleed

I'm NOT watching the rest of the show...

My only problem with The World I Know is this (because I think he did a BEAUTIFUL job on it)--

Its not nearly as well known as Imagine, and sometimes that can hurt.
Not to those that just appreciate any good music and performance, but for a lot of on the fence types...
I fear they'll go with the familiar.
Six minutes until voting my ass off begins...

They say simon doesn't look pleased with Simon's response?
That true?

he made me cry he's so right i'm going to watch dial idol like a hawk because archuleta is being pimped so bad right now imagine figures lets vote!

then Archie sings that one song he already knows the judges love.
I love what David said though "This is a progression."

Guys thanks for posting what's happening. Cant believe that rounds 1 & 2 are for archie. We have to vote, vote, vote for DC since we can't have the judges on our side. We know what DC is capable of and we all know that he's talented and he really deserves to be the winner. So keep voting guys.

Ok East Coasters get ready to VOTE!!!!!

Now I think Simon played his game in a very twisted way. You made our David cry, Simon, and I won't forget what you just did, EVER!!! Now, let's vote, vote, vote. DC should win this thing and I don't care if all 3 rounds goes to little David.

i think david a is gonna win :'(.
VOTE VOTE VOTE FOR COOOOK <3!
HE NEEDS EVERY VOTEE!!

I'm very disappointed with the judges. I agree with David....why rehash something in the past and not keep going?

Well, this has certainly been an experience. I know that I will vote the whole 4 hours. I hope that those who have experienced David's work this season will come forward and support him.

Jeannine

omg i don't what am gonna do if he doesn't win.... =( i have to vote vote vote

yes keep voting guys
i still believe he will win!!!!

"IMAGINE" that Archie did the song again.... blah blah blahh.. I HATE THAT KID (nothing personallyy...)