Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Kelly Clarkson Used Carly's Song?!
David Cook > The Other Stuff > American Idol (General)
StephyDee
Ok, on iTunes I decided to check out Carly's album which came out in 2001....remember that year....

I put in "Carly Hennessy", and the name came up, and if you look in the album "Ultimate High", there's a song called "Just Missed The Train".... dry.gif


....if anyone owns Kelly Clarkson's debut cd, "Thankful", they are probably this right now: O_o

The songs are the same...EXACTLY the same....and Kelly's cd came out in 2002/2003...I forget which year....I think 2003 though....

....so in thinking about it, it's weird, because Carly's had this connection with American Idol for so long.....not to mention it might be hidden payback to her record company or whatever, ALSO because she's been compared to Kelly Clarkson....(IRONYYYYY) huh.gif

Then again, it makes you wonder....does she KNOW that Kelly used her song? I know it's probably not HER song, but still....Carly originally sung it.....it's a pretty song by far, and it's weird to see that she sung it BEFORE Kelly, and since at the time she wasn't popular at all, so the record producers just took it from under her and used it for American Idol winner Kelly Clarkson!

....it reminds me eeriely of "Dreamgirls".....get what I'm saying?

What do you guys think of this?

EDIT:....this song is like leftovers! Turns out an artist named Maarja sung it back in 1998!

...this is an old song then! laugh.gif


EDIT NUMBER TWO: Ok, so this song is REALLLYYYY OLD! Trine Rein sung it back in 1993!
Team D.C!
QUOTE (StephyDee @ Apr 2 2008, 11:03 AM) *
EDIT:....this song is like leftovers! Turns out an artist named Maarja sung it back in 1998!

...this is an old song then! laugh.gif

EDIT NUMBER TWO: Ok, so this song is REALLLYYYY OLD! Trine Rein sung it back in 1993!


HAHAHAHAHA looks like you solved your own mystery then! smile.gif

Maybe it's one of those songs that's remade like 9273739575726182011928181618192 times rofl happy.gif
StephyDee
QUOTE (Team D.C! @ Apr 1 2008, 10:11 PM) *
HAHAHAHAHA looks like you solved your own mystery then! smile.gif

Maybe it's one of those songs that's remade like 9273739575726182011928181618192 times rofl happy.gif

I didn't have a mystery to solve...just wanted people to see it rofl....

....the irony is still there, but now it's just diluted! laugh.gif

....and by the looks of it, that song probably WAS remade 9273739575726182011928181618192 times! ROFL

Kelly's version is still the best, though...
blankmind3
Yeah, Kelly's is lol
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2012 Invision Power Services, Inc.