Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Farewell Malubay
David Cook > The Other Stuff > American Idol (General)
Zeta_Nova
It's always hard to see someone leave in Idol. Which in this season, Cook was like a brother figure to the 20 yr old Malubay (which's called; Kuya). So, along with the IGB. He also probably shed some tears due to Malubay leaving.

Dangerous Heart
She never should have been eliminated. Kristy should have went, because Ramiele at least HAS a good voice that I can listen to, & not want to stab myself in the ear drums everytime I hear her... [Yeah I'm rude to Kristy, because she doesn't deserve to be there still].

I'll definitely miss Ramiele there, because she was talented, I just think her picking the right songs was a problem for her. I think she'll have a good career though if she gets picked up by a label, definitely.
SzTheDay
I was sad to see her go as well.  I am looking for KLC or Syesha to go next - PLEASE.  Does anyone know how petite Ramielle is?
SzTheDay
Nevermind - must found out she's 4'11". I'm a whole inch taller! tongue.gif
-Ross
It was sad seeing her go, plus watching the memories was even more depressing. And being a Filipino myself, i just wished she could stay longer.

Kuya David <-- sounds nice, dont cha think> ;D
luvindc
I didn't want Ramiele to go, but she hasn't been consistent with her performances as well as KLC, but KLC should've been gone since the Top 16. Ramiele chose songs that were too big for her or she tackled a previous AI performer song (Alone - Carrie Underwood). No one is going to sing it like Carrie. You really don't want to be compared on the show and I think that's the problem that everybody is going to run into at one time or another. If you sing a song a winner or any other contestant has sung, and had high praise for it, don't sing it, bad choice. anyone else agree?
Dangerous Heart
^^ I wouldn't agree on the song choice thing of picking one that a previous winner did, because I'm sure there are people that can blow that previous singer away. Know what I mean?
I think sometimes, some of the contestants just try to pick something that will show off that vocal range, & can sometimes come off as being too big of a song for them.

Everyone has their own take a song, & maybe they don't always remember that previous AI contestants/winners, had sung those songs.
but the fact that the judges go back to previous competitors, & compare the performances is stupid in general anyway. They should be judging what the CURRENT person did on it, not tearing it apart because of something someone before them had done. Know what I mean?

K I'm done haha.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2012 Invision Power Services, Inc.