I think Roger looks hotter, but i wanna know what YOU peeps think!

Hmm...I've never found Roger Federer that attractive at all. I think he looks too much like Quentin Tarrantino.

So I'm definitely going to have to go with david

David wins this one again. Roger Federer's not attractive to me at all.

Actually, I would say Rafael Nadal! I adore him. Roger is pretty cool too. I think all 3 of them are pretty hot.

Amen to that, although IMO Roger is hottest, followed by Rafa and David.

Ok totally had to google Roger Federer to find out who he is.

And David Cook hands down!!

i love me some roger but i definitely think david is hotter

Ok, I googled Roger. David much hotter...much...much..hotter, hey but the guy ain't bad(Roger).

david of course! only david for now...

Guess I need to google cause I have no idea who this is.

There's no one hotter than Cookie!

Totally agree! David is IT!

Sorry Roger Federer is fugly but Rafael Nadal's arms, OH MY GOD! Still not on the same planet sexy-wise as DC though!

DC wins!!!

DC has that 'inner sexiness' that makes him atop.

This whole thread has me wondering, how many of the people who have answered are tennis fans? I know some of you aren't because you said you needed to google Roger, lol.

Because I know before I saw David sing or listened to his interviews or anything, if you'd just showed me a picture of him, even though he's good looking I wouldn't have been instantly in love or anything. He really grew on me week by week as I got to know more about him and could appreciate his talent and intelligence.

So I have the same thing going on with Roger and Rafa because I'm a big tennis fan and have been watching them play, seen their interviews, and so on, for years now. I feel like I know something more about them than just looking at a picture. One of the reasons I am such a big Rafa fan is because he is such an awesome person. Roger is too by the way, it's just that when Andre retired, Rafa became my guy.

Rafael Nadal

See, I am right the opposite. Don't get me wrong those guys are hot. But, I was instantly attracted to David, I guess I have a thing for rocker/grungy guys. I loved his faux hawk, and when he smile, even for that brief second, I was smitten.

Yeah, it's been interesting reading the topic on here about that, "when did David have you hooked" or something like that. Some people just fell for him the minute they laid eyes on him and others fell more slowly over the course of the weeks of the competition.

DAVID COOK is WAAAYYYY way way HOTTER!!

I'm glad I'm not the only one who had to google Roger Federer to find out who he is. I'm not a tennis fan (obviously), but I wouldn't mind watching him run around the court! Cute, but no contest. David David David.

Carole
#24 X-rated Cougar

Hey Carole,

Yeah, if you're not a tennis fan it's definitely no contest. You have to be into the game to appreciate these guys, I think. They are poetry in motion on the court! Speaking of cougars, Roger really moves like a cat, he's amazing to watch.

I love tennis and even though Roger is pretty attractive, I deff. still have to go with David Cook!!!!

I love roger, but I definitley think David is a lot hottter!!!

Seeing as how I have absolutely no clue who Roger Federer is, I'm gonna have to throw my vote Dave's way, yet again.

Roger Federer? who? hee

I had to Google Roger Federer because I had no idea who he was. Once I did, let me tell you I still think that DAVID COOK IS A MILLION TIMES HOTTER.

I have been a big fan of tennis for years. Roger and Rafa are both pretty sexy. Roger is amazing in that he is so good on the tennis court no one can close to his talent level. And that is sexy! But I have much more time invested in DC and love everything about him, so for right now I would have to pick DC.

Another easy one, David, for sure .

...for those that are confuzed like I was
Roger:


.....

David:


.....


~*yep, David wins *~

So those of you that are tennis fans, would you like to see Roger and Rafa in the Wimbledon finals again this year?

Poetry in Motion!!!!!

Well, I knew who Roger Federer was without Googling him, and it is obvious to me that I think David is MUCH hotter because I am not a member of Roger's fan club nor do I obsess over him 24/7. Here's a good pic of Roger:



Boy would I love to see DC without his shirt on!

Woo-hoo! This was my 100th post!

Wow, nice pic of the Rog! Thanks! Hadn't seen that.

Yeah, one of DC would be cool, he was even wearing a t-shirt in those pool pics with the dolphin, darn it.

haha I did the same!

and Yes, David!

I googled him too!
Lol. David. No question about it.
hahahah. Sorry, Roger, no thanks.

You're welcome!

I think I heard DC say in an interview that he wasn't ready to go shirtless - not quite toned enough or something like that. He said he lost some 10-15 pounds during Idol, not drinking (alcohol), eating better, and working out. Probably not comfortable in his new skin yet.

David! of course

Cookie of course!!! He's the Hotest guy on this planet!!

I guess that's the problem with a question like this, it's all in the eye of the beholder. Asking who's hotter on the David Cook forum is going to get you some pre-ordained answers, lol.

Not saying David isn't incredibly hot, don't get me wrong. But if you post the same question over on Roger's fansite you'd get different answers. I'm just sayin'.....

I find David to be the most beautiful person on this earth.

So um David.

I'll second this:)

Wow, I bet this thread has gone on alot longer than the O.P. ever expected! LOL

Completely off topic, sorry! But!

I used to live so close to Wimbledon that I could hear the crowd roaring from my garden and I never went, lol.

You used to spend as little time there as you could when the tournament was on because you just kept tripping over lost, bewildered tourists, lol.

But I did work as a court coverer as a student one summer. Trouble was it was the only summer on record where the temp was in the 80s for the whole tournament and so I laid on Wimbledon Common for 2 weeks getting a tan with my friends! Those were the days!

I'm glued to the television during Wimbledon so I'm very familiar with the court coverers, LOL. Boy do they get those courts covered fast!!!!

to me, it's no contest. david cook.

COOK FOREVER, the sexiest ever.

not into tennis,so I had to look the dude up...DC all the way baby!

YYYESSSSSS!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I'd love to see another Roger-Rafa final!!!! Hopefully Roger wins!!

Sorry, but I vote for David..

[/size]OH MY GOD I GOT SO EXCITED WHEN I SAW THIS THREAD LOL

[size="3"]sorry lol...it's just these are my two fave guys I love em and I'm sorry to say but I think Roger is hotter! I just came back from Wimbledon I got to meet Roger and Rafa on Monday 23rd and a few others too, but they are my two faves. They are so sweet and both are very hot! I couldn't resist posting my pic of Roger here but make sure to look at a David Cook one after it so it's ok lol

I know what the answer to this question will be on this site! I almost ask, why ask?!!

I don't think Roger Federer is attractive at all. David wins, by far.

David Cook