Okay. I know it's hard, but I want to see what you guys would pick.. SoOo.. if you had to take one of david's most beautiful quality away from him, what would it be??

Oh sh*t that's kind of easy for me... He could ditch his politeness.

good one

His ability to play the violin. It doesn't influence him as a person, and its still a quality. So, I win.

oh nothing!
i don't know him personally but base from what i see on tv, yeah! he's not perfect but i still like him the way he is.

Good thinking! I concur.

yeah.... i'm not a big violin freak.. so that wouldn't bother me if he didn't play violin...lol.

No! You can't say "nothing"! That's the thing of it.... You have to pick something. I know he's close to perfect so that's the challenge .

This is really hard...I'm trying but....

maybe his nail biting - but then I love his man hands..nah not that,

maybe his extra pointy cowboy boots. I love his boots in general, I think they are hot - but the pointy ones just don't do it for me. Not really a quality - but he is always wearing them???

Just thought of one - I hate the fedora type hat - he can keep the baseball caps - but ditch the other one.

Lol. HIS FAME!
Because then I could go hunt him down and have him for myself!



Than fedora is smokin'. I say ditch the baseball caps!

DC4breakfast, you ,hands down, have the best signature ever. lol

Wow, thanks so much. I just made it hoping you guys would like it! That is a real compliment considering all the great graphics you've got around here!

i LOVE the pointy boots... b/c i don't see anybody else wearing them... it's his own thing and original!!.. and i love the Fedora hat!!.. he can pull it off!!




LOLOLOL.. good Answer!!!

This is so very difficult, but if I must take something away I'd go for the pointy boots as well, he can always get himself another less pointy pair.

Haha. My graphics are awful, but it's true that they are amazing around here.
I really like yours though.
It incorporates 3 of my favorite pictues and that quote is amazing!



*bows*
haha.

Good choice

I'd take away the way he say's 'yeah'...because he is so well spoken and then he says 'yeah' rather than 'yes'...Picky I know!

What would I like to see gone???


Actually, I was watching where the kids interviewed and I was struck with all of the "um"s each time he was asked a question. Hopefully he will lose that as he gets more experience interviewing.

Just make me a poster so I can stare at it all day.

I think he's great and really wouldn't want to change anything. But if I had to pick something, I'm not wild about the fedora hat either. Of course, it's not a showstopper. He's talented, hot, and a good guy. Who can ask for more?

LOL. I forgot about the violin playing...but I bet if he played something cool on it, along with some killer eye candy we would still melt.



I love it too. Wish i could have one on my wall. You all do such creative and cool things. I felt lucky to get a few words scrawled on the bottom.

Ooh, perfect. But if I couldn't do that, then his boots.

Oh, and he needs a little less beard and a little more scruff lately. Ditch the beard, give us the 5 o'oclock shadow!

But really I love everything about him, even that stuff, because it's HIM.

DC4Breakfast - yes, your siggy is great! I love the wording!

If I could take one thing away it would be his boots. I love his hats, the violen thing is kinda cool in a weird way, it's more culteral or whatever, and without his fame we would have never been introduced to him. I like the way he says "um" and "yeah" it's like...I dunno my own connection or whatever with him, because whenever I think about what to say I always say "um" plus I tend to say "yeah" quite a bit.

So, yeah....I think the only thing I could really do without would have to be those boots, they can be dangerous sometimes, and we wouldn't want him to have a replay of what happened with the white boots from Idol Gives Back.

This is a difficult one, because as far as his 'admirable personality' (which he presents to the public) is concerned; there's not one I would want to take away. I only hope that he stays true to how he defines success; and continuous to be proper, mannerly and polite which is so 'rare nowadays amongst our young men'.

However, as far a physical appearance is concerned; I thought he has such a good complexion for it to be hidden under a lot of facial hair. Less would be better in my opinion.

wow this is a really hard question.... If I HAD to take one quality away from David Cook it would have to be............how he doesn't give himself enough credit. Is that a quality? Like when Simon apologized to him david said it wasn't needed when I was glad that Simon apologized to him because if he wouldn't have, I would probablly still hate simon. lol

I know what you mean. He wouldn't be the same without the scruff, but sometimes it looks like it is growing into a beard. Don't grow a beard Cookie!!

lol yes no beard just scruff..Scruff is good. Beard no so good

This is a really hard question for me, because as a whole I love everything about him. It's what makes him HIM!!! But since I HAVE to choose, I'd say I would take away his skinniess.. I want him to put some meat back on his bones!! I like him with a little cushion for the pushin'.. if ya know what I'm sayin'??

WHY would anyone want him to "ditch" his politeness????

not putting anyone down, just a curious observation.

Oh wow, this is hard!

How about.....Hs big feet! (...it doesn't really matter now!)

Wow this is really hard, how do take soemthing away from perfection hmmmm??

I guess I would have to go with the beard, I love the scruff..... but I don't like a beard so that would be my choice

wait, he plays the violin?
i didn't know that!


on to the thread topic, i would say his pointy boots, sorry but i ain't a fan of them hehe
but i think take from him as a person or physically, well...ooh...that's hard...his looks? honestly, if he wasn't even good looking i would like him anyway because he's just too perfect for words

What happened with the white boots from Idol Gives Back??

Take away the beard. It's got to be scruff. No beard.

When it was idol gives back they were rehearsing and he was trying to heel spin - and then fell on his butt. Or to use his words 'I bit it - like hard'!!

You can see it on the embarassing moments video.

I don't like the pointy boots eather!!! He should start wearing his black converse again he looks totaly hot in those!!! I'm not crazy about eather hat too just give me sex hair and I'm happy!!! I'm also not fond of the beard he needs to go back to scruffyness prefection!!!!

No one here is diggin' the pointy boots!
I'm not necessarily a huge fan of the booties, but I'm definately not a fan of Converse (*dodges the thrown popcorn*) But I do agree that he needs to shave... or at least do somewhat of a 'trim'

But if there was one actual quality I could do without, it would absolutely be his over politeness... I'm not saying that I wish he was a dick, it's just sometimes.... He needs to tell people what he really thinks lol. Like, I just want to hear him tell someone to fuck off or something ahaha.
I suppose though, that his politeness is what sets him apart from everyone else in his 'genre'... all rockers are douches (stereotypically speaking) and that's like the opposite of David (from what we see)

I'm putting way too much thought into this lol..

I use to say "um" constanly when I was younger cuz I had an really bad stuttering problem I would say "um" a dozen times and never be able to get out what I wanted to say. But now I hardly say it at all. I do still stutter on ocation when I'm nervus. I am sure seeing David face to face would turn me into a quivering drooling mess that would be soooo embaresing!! I pray to God that wouldn't happen but it probubly would!!! I'm almost to 200 post yay!!!!

His taste in women.

(Travis, just trying to be funny - don't close the thread please!)

I would give anything to see that clip of him biting it HARD in his Tom Jones white boots. I can't believe that never showed up somewhere. There seems to be a camera on them every second.

haha!
you're selfish..

You know you'd do the same thing! Don't lie!

The wool neck scarf and the entire look he had in the photo that came with iTunes purchases.
(That is the least attractive he ever looked; such a shame iTunes locked on to that photo.)

His hair: I think David has problem hair and it will always be something of a problem. He has tried many styles and he keeps getting it better, and he makes the best of it, but it will always require an effort and never be great.

I love his personality, his intelligence, his kindness, his smile, his eyes, his complexion, his voice, his moves, ...
there are no actual "qualities" I'd change.

I didn't have the guts to say that.

why would you do this???????NUTS I TELL YOU. THIS IS ABSOLUTE NUTS. (no i don't mean i would take away his nuts.) if "had to take" implies punishment for not doing so, then punish me (of course,i would prefer Mr.Cook do the punishing himself.) i refuse to strip him of any inner or physical qualities that make him the man he is/ i love. and when time and experience break in for the steal, i'll still love him. i also believe that time and experience will add more beautiful qualities to him; i would rather share in this, than take from him......i'm in trouble, am i not? **essie**

I'll take the new beard away , love the scruff, no beard for me, please.

HA! I was just thinking I would absolutely NOT change a thing, but I have to agree with ya, Rhoda. He still looks pretty darn HOT right now, but I do not want to see him lose any more weight.

CUSHION FOR THE PUSHIN' Gotcha girl!!! You are awesome!!!!

lol I loved that 2 'cushion for the pushin' that was very clever. Kudos on that. and I totally agree there

Where do ya find "embarassing Moments" video at?????

AHHHH lets see If ya HAD to take something away ...........Who said his BIG FEET, are you a mad woman???? I would say less beard also , I'm not a beard kinda gal....... scruff sexy .....beard ..no not so much!! And Rhoda mention put a little more meat back on those bones I'm all for that girl.....agreed!!

Okay, I know he's not that tall, but I would take away his height. You'd still just get the same amazing David, but just in a slightly smaller package.

FEET was me! ROFL! It's not like it's giving away secret information now...everybody knows what kind of guns DC is packing! When the holster if splitting at the seams...it's a dead givaway!