First of all - CONGRATULATIONS go out to David Cook for being FEARLESS in his song choice last night..

It was inspirational week and he choose a song called "Innocent" - how perfect is that? I think that the main reason the judges were harsh is because they don't know who Our Lady Peace is and that is a shame.

I just watched their video for Innocent and the song is AMAZING.. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mi2uOsApqII
And I think that David did a GREAT job with it.


Well, I know that some people will say David had an off week, but maybe they just didn't get the theme last night..


I have to say that the judges were off to me and the fact that they loved Jason's performance proved it- NO WAY IN HELL that he was better than David... ( are they freakin' serious?? That was lame and boring and NOT inspiring at all!)

DAVID COOK was brilliant, fearless and emotional and I loved it! and I loved that he stayed true to himself!

THANK YOU DAVID COOK FOR ANOTHER GREAT PERFORMANCE!!!

that was very well said and i couldn't agree more

Ditto I sort of realized that the judges weren't going to get it. Kinda scares me that there's viewers who will vote just on a performance based on what the judges say. There's no way that Cookie should be as low as he is. Then again, those perdiction could be waaaay off.

OMG, I totally agree about Jason Castro's joke of a performance!!!!
And then I was like whaaaaaa????!!!!! when they raved about it, and yet what they said about DC's, gimme a BREAK!!!!!!!!!!

I believe the song means a lot to him; that is way he wanted to do it. I think ohe did a great job; not his best - but he did an amazing job.

I kept saying "I think Paula slipped something in their drinks" all night
Randy and Simon were completely off the mark on almost everything.

Exactly...
They were like .... We're grumpy... We're so grumpy tonight!

This is actually probably my favorite song that he has done although in the begining it was a little rough I love love love love love this song it's one of my favs and I can listen to it over and over and over but anyways I was so darn happy when he song it and it had meaning behind it and also I loved how it showed the rawness or whatever it is in his voice I thought it was good the studio isn't bad either but kinda seems a little too toned down but not bad though

Which song did Jason sing? Over the Rainbow was it?? I liked it. I have the studio one on my iPod. But as far as David goes, I thought the begining was rough as well, but I really liked it.

I love Our Lady Peace.
I'm happy that David Cook and I have something in common!
Oh wait!
We're both left-handed, we like word puzzles (I'm nerdy) and we play guitar.

In AI when David announced that he going to play that song, I was surprise in a good way. I love that song and David did a great job.

"Innocent" is prolly my favorite DC performance to date.

i totally agree!!! he's such a stud.

After listening to the original...David did amazing!

This is one of my best DCs performances. I think he did a great job. I had a problem with getting it at first, I was confused, I just wasn't expecting that, but after I saw it second time I got it. After so many weeks, I do not come back that often to his Bilie Jean or Hello kinda videos as much as I come back to this one. He was so insperational here. I love it. And I love his hair in this one