Who do you think the bottom three will be this week? I'd love to hear some opinions on this, because I'm a bit up in the air about it now.

Or better yet: Who would be your bottom three?

My bottom three...

Syesha, KLC, Jason.

IMO the perfect bottom three. And Syesha leaving. Id rather see her leave and KLC stay ONE more week.

Sorry to any of those who are fans of theirs.

No hatred here, Rye. I understand. I think I figured mine out finally. It took me a lot of thinking.

My preferred bottom three would be the same as Makinsey's. But I think the actual bottom three will be David Cook, Carly Smithson and Kristy Lee Cook, with Carly going.

And let me have it on the record that I really hope I'm wrong. I actually adore Carly.

Carly
Syesha
KLC

either one could go home though

Carly, Syesha, and Michael, with Carly going home, although I think it should be Syesha.

My personal bottom three would be Carly, KLC, and Syesha, with KLC going home.

I think the actual bottom three will be Brooke, Carly and Syesha, with either Carly or Syesha going home.

bottom 3 and don't hate me for this:

david cook ; carly and syesha


with david being safe.

Obviously you know who my top three is.

But I agree with T.C. Robson. I love Carly too, but she might just be leaving... *tear*




Oh, and off topic, Rye, is it okay if i use this blend of yours in my sig?

ok i hope and prey this dial idol thing isent laget but it says on there that david will be in the bottom three no i sure hope not it dont say hes going home but still that is very disturbing to know that i hope its wrong....

You should take the DialIdol results with a grain of salt. They are nice as a guideline and usually give you a pretty good idea of who will be safe and who won't, but it's not 100% accurate. For the past two or three weeks they've had at least one person in the bottom three wrong, and they have been wrong about who's going home a couple of times too.

My preferred bottom 3 would be KLC, Syesha, and Brooke with KLC going home. The actual bottom 3 I think will be Syesha, Carly, and Michael/David C.

Kristy, Brooke, and Syesha.

Kristy goes home, although from what I can tell, she will be safe. I really can't stand hearing her perform every week. Her voice is so annoying to me.

I think this week's bottom three will be KLC, Carly and Syesha. And maybe, just maybe, Carly will be sent home.

Shame on everyone who says DC might be in the bottom three, just because you didn't like his song Tuesday. He has been the most consistant contestant on the show. He has WOWed everyone each week except for a few nay says that doesn't like anyone. If he is in the bottom three it will be a great shame. Just my opinion.

i really dont think that david will be in the bottom 3.
didnt you guys here all the fans screaming and shreking with delight as soon as he started singing about her "hands on his waist, chest to chest, face to face"?????? *starts panting with sexual exitement, and plans to rip the head off that dancer who had her hands all over him*
he clearly has many fans, and just because he had one week that he wasnt as good as he usually is, doesnt mean he is gonna be in the bottom 3.
i mean, look at all the other contestants that have had terrible weeks, and they've mad it through!!! for example, KLC, no one really likes her anyways, but she keeps makin it through, week after week, even when she has terrible performances and the judges trash her.

all we can do is wait with bated breath for tonights show!!!!!!!!!
good luck david, you're the love of my liiiiife

I predict.. Michael, Carly and Syesha with Syesha going home.

And I am expecting Ryan to make a BIG SCENE when DC comes out and taking a LOOOOOOOOOOOOONG time to announce that he is safe this week- leave it to Ryan to drag it out just a bit longer than necessary!

Yeah I can hear him now...David, you are..... going to have to wait til after our commercial break..

I think it will be Syesha, Brooke and Carly (as much as I don't like her, I think KLC just may hang on 1 more week after this song) with Syesha going home.

hello....
DC cant be in bottom 3 ... he has a ver loyal fan base which will not disappoint him!!!

syesha goes home!!!!! or maybe KLC (hate her for no convincing reason!!)

I would put KLC, Carly and Syesha with either of them going home...

But I'm still really afraid that David will be in the bottom 3, but even if he is... I'm 100% sure he's safe!

Syesha's a popular choice for this thread, I'm noticing...

Who were in bottom three?

Carly, syesha and MJ

1. Syesha
2. Carly
3. KLC

I know it's not a popularity contest but I really would like to see Syesha and Carly gone because of they're personalities.

i agree. but i would like to see all the girls, but Brooke gone.

my dream bottom three would be (don't get mad) Syesha, Kristy and Brooke. Kristy would go out, then the next week would be Syesha out, brooke and Jason. i know a lot of ppl like jason, but 2 me he is sort of boring.

i think the bottom three will be carly, syesha and kristy
i think

David C and Carly rock!

Except David is super close to Carly--and with MJ gone, it would be nice to leave him with one buddy! She's actually really starting to grow on me. The other two, however, I won't shed any tears over when they go...

I would put Syesha, Kristy, and Brooke in the bottom three. My guess would be that Syesha would be the one going home on Wednesday.

usually in the bottom 3 they put someone in there that is like a SHOCK - someone you are pretty sure, won't go home.

i agree...since i really think Brooke might have a hard time this week. But i pick (could it finally happen? maybe?) Kristy will go home.

I don't think kristi will go home because she hasn't been in the bottom 3 for like 2 freakin weeks...
besides, you've got to consider that some people other than vote for the worst actually ENJOY kristy *shock*

Does anyone remember... you know how this season had a weird Hollywood week? When the people that were going out had one last ten-second chance to make it through? The only reason Kristy got through was from singing Amazing Grace-her audition song! Hmmm... almost out at the beginning of Hollywood week to being a top 7 icon of sorts...

For the love of donuts please let it be Syesha that gets the boot! can't stand her she can't last one more friggin week.

Kristy,Brooke,Carly

Brooke, Syesha and Carly.
Seyesha going home...finally. Hopefully I should say.

Brooke, Syesha & Carly

While I hope it's Syesha going home..I believe it will be Brooke

I think it will be Syesha, Carly and Kristy. I'd like it to be Syesha, Kristy and Archie with a major shocker of Archie going home.

THAT would be sweet! ~insert evil laugh~ mwahahaha!

That's my B3 too..I hope it's Syesha too. Brooke and Carly don't deserve to go.

Syesha, Kristy, Carly. Please and thank you!
Too bad there can't be a triple-elimination tonight. I'd like that.

Alright, so, my bottom three for this week:

Syesha, Carly and Kristy...as most of you have said. I think it's a given.

My prediction to go home is Syesha (even though she was my prediction last week and we all know what happened there ). I think Kristy still has a week or two left in her, unfortunately. As much as I love Jason Castro, I'm not sure if he's going to be around very much longer either. My dream top 3 is Jason, David A. and DC, but who knows?

~Steph

My guessed bottom 3:

Brooke, Carly, KLC.

Carly's going home.


But I think it could be Brooke or Carly going, and either Syesha or KLC in the bottom 3 (but both of them safe).


And hey, DC BETTER be safe with his brother there -- that would just be AWFUL!

According to Dialidol.com/ (It's Official)
David Cook is safe and is number 1!
Bottom 3 from Dialidol.com (It's Offical)
Carly, Brooke & Syesha
Syesha is going home this week on Idol!

But weren't they wrong when MJ went home?